ED BREEN MOMENT

By Ed Breen

We – you and I and the millions of men and women who live in small communities from the Atlantic to the Pacific – live in what is euphemistically called “fly-over country,” those cities and towns which the media and the marketing gurus believe to be irrelevant,  populated by people who do not a have a place at the table  because we are too old, too stupid, too straight, too poor, too uncouth to contribute much.

Fly-over country used to be more geographical than it is today. I recall being on a plane from Indianapolis to someplace in the far west years ago and when we got into either Oklahoma or Kansas air space – and I can’t recall which it was – the flight attendants hovered in the aisles to take our drinks away from us because we were 32,000 feet above a place in which to drink alcohol was to sin. We flew over and they returned our drinks a few minutes later at the next state line.  I don’t know that the aggrieved states were prepared to shoot us out of the sky for failure to comply, but we did.

As money, power, influence, people and jobs gravitated to the big cities we increasingly lost not only our livelihoods but our self-respect.

A year ago now, the Community Foundation  of Grant County  brought a fellow to town, a man named  Ben Winchester, a Minnesotan and fellow fly-over victim, who tried to disabuse us of this notion. You are not, he said, in the middle of nowhere, you are in the middle of everywhere. He is right, of course, but it is still a tough sell.

Now he has been joined by a big-time serious journalist who is telling us the same thing. He is James Fallows, a former reporter, editor, boss of the Atlantic magazine and once a speech writer for President Jimmy Carter.

Fallows, who was from small-town America himself, albeit a California small town, has teamed with his wife,  Debra, a Buckeye by birth, to give us a fresh look at ourselves in both a book and an HBO TV special called, appropriately, “Our Towns.”

The great irony of the Fallows’ work is that they compressed the necessary time to visit fly-over country by flying to us rather than over us. Fallows is a pilot and the two of them hopscotched the nation from  Lackawanna, N. Y., to Redlands, Calif., and 40 other towns in between in their own small aircraft. That allowed more time in places like Vermillion, Ohio,  and Eastport, Maine, and Sioux Falls, S.D. , to talk to the rest of us.

And the important thing is what they talked about, what they discussed with the folks on and off Main Street in 42 towns.  After they completed their book a couple of years ago, they made another journey to our part of the country to tell us what they had found. Among the stops on that trek were stops in Muncie and Fort Wayne, not to preach but to inform.  But let Mr. Fallows tell you a bit of it:

“We avoided national politics,” he  said, “because of the depth and dimensionality of people’s views when you ask them about things they know.”